Posted 9th November 2011 | 7 Comments

Network Rail insiders blamed for some cable thefts

SOME Network Rail staff and contractors are cable thieves, according to a senior manager.

The problem of metal thefts is becoming worse as the value of some metals, particularly copper, continues to rise on world markets, and there are increasingly strident calls for the scrap metal trade to be licensed and regulated.

The revelation about the involvement of some Network Rail insiders came from operational services directory Dyan Crowther, when she was giving evidence to the House of Commons transport committee.

She told the hearing that the staff and contractors working on projects inevitably had inside knowledge about where and when a signalling scheme was taking place.

She said: "There is evidence that there is inside knowledge. There have been arrests and prosecutions of Network Rail staff who have been involved in cable theft."

"It's almost like providing sweets in a sweet shop," she added.

With the incidence of thefts and resulting rail disruption getting worse, British Transport Police have described the present system of controlling the scrap metal trade as dating from the days of Steptoe and Son.

BTP deputy chief constable Paul Crowther told the committee that legislation had not kept pace with modern conditions.

Describing railway cable theft as a 'low-risk, high-return activity', the deputy chief constable said: "When you go to scrap metal dealers you give your name and address and there are no means of knowing if the information is true. We have a risk and reward balance which is in favour of the criminal."

Virgin Trains is the latest industry member to campaign for tighter controls on the handling of scrap metals, after its services have been disrupted on numerous occasions by thefts of equipment on the West Coast Main Line.

VT's chief operating officer Chris Gibb was joined at Coventry station on Monday this week by representatives of British Transport Police, London Midland and the security company SmartWater to distribute information about the problem, and what it is being done to combat it.

The West Midlands is one of the country's hot-spots for cable thefts, and Mr Gibb said: "Cable theft continues to be an escalating threat to Virgin Trains’ customers and the economy. In 2010/11 there were 6,000 hours of train delay related to more than 3,000 crimes, and British Transport Police made more than 900 arrests. The trend so far this year is worse, despite a 20 per cent drop in the price of copper. On a single day recently Virgin Trains experienced 60 hours of delay.

“The cost to the railways alone reaches around £19 million a year to replace lost cable and to compensate passenger and freight operators for the delays caused, while the wider impact on lost business and productivity accounts for another £19 million.

“But cable theft is not a victimless crime. Delayed customers are people with lives to lead – jobs to get to, family to see and hospital appointments to make. The cable thieves are disrupting people's lives."

Reader Comments:

Views expressed in submitted comments are that of the author, and not necessarily shared by Railnews.

  • dave barry, wallasey, england

    the govt keep saying they will change the law to catch more dealers...and saying....and saying...nothing done though for well over a year of saying

  • Rajat B, London, United Kingdom

    This is not like theft of a laptop or a mobile that easy to dispose and near impossible to trace. Its a heavy product that would require visible handling, movement and masking before its reaches scrap dealers. Then again the scrap dealers could not be totally oblivious about the product source. Its surprising that culprits, main or part of the chain are not being brought to book fast enough.

  • Anon, Derby

    Cable theft will unlikely cause an accident. Signalling and control systems are fail safe - which means, when cables is stolen, signals go back to red.

    Theft of cable causes operational issues and delay.

  • John Gilbert, Cradley, Herefordshire, England

    Well of course I'm not surprised. With the abyssmal level of morals in this country these days such an outcome is to be expected and must therefore be guarded against. The question is, how soon will those gormless asses in Whitehall and Westminster act to close loopholes? On normal performance not very quickly - but one never knows, perhaps they will be different this time. But don't hold your breath!

  • H Harvey, Birmingham

    PS the industry I was once in had this problem in the 1970s/1980s Insiders were involved then.
    But problem was for years cable was left at roadside and was quite safe. But 'social change' changed all that Just had to be less trusting.
    Difference is NOW two loade Pendolinos at 125mph crashing into each other could be 1000 dead never mind delay minutes
    GOVERNMENT must act now at national level

  • H Harvey, Birmingham

    If cable theft not halted there will be a massive loss of life in rail accident.
    A special group should be constituted by Govt including BTP and National police force as a matter of urgency.
    Failure of politicians to act will mean public will hold them to blame and rightly so

  • Steve Alston, Crewe

    Think many of us already knew this. No surprise that as soon as a random section of brand new cable went down, it came back up again.

    The whole scrap metal sales industry should be banned and nationalised, it's the only solution, something this shortsighted government wouldn't bear to do.